I See a Cat

September 1, 2017

PreS-Gr 1-Another great addition to the series by Meisel (See Me Run and See Me Dig), again featuring the always-popular antics of a dog. The story begins (and ends) with the animated pup barking up a tree. The title page creates interest and draws readers in with the image of an unhappy dog coming inside. The rest of the story depicts the pup's reactions to various encounters inside and out. Spreads full of bright colors and cartoonish illustrations clearly portray the dog's feelings through his actions and expressions. The simple text includes merely 10 words. Each sentence begins with, "I see a..." and ends with the latest entry into the dog's field of vision, including a cat, bird, fly, bee, mice, a boy, and-most frustratingly and more than once-a squirrel. The repetition in the simple text and sentence structure will build confidence for early readers. VERDICT A great choice for early readers that will have wide appeal and could be read individually or with a group. Recommended for general purchase.-Theresa Muraski, University of Wisconsin-Stevens Point Library

Copyright 2017 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.

Starred review from June 15, 2017
Ten words may be all it takes to convince some young children to try reading. An expressive dog, locked inside on a sunny day, is increasingly frustrated by its confinement. Each sentence begins: "I see a...." "Cat," "bird," "fly," "squirrel," "mice," "bee," and so on complete the sentence on successive subsequent double-page spreads. Almost all the action takes place on the other side of a sliding-glass door. Only the fly is inside, buzzing annoyingly around the dog in four vignettes. When a brown-skinned child appears, the dog is clearly delighted. Freed at last, the dog immediately chases the squirrel up a tree. Despite its limited vocabulary, Meisel's simple story is surprisingly satisfying. New readers will fill in the missing details from clues in the uncluttered illustrations, several spreads of which are completely wordless. For example, the child is first shown with a backpack--just returning home from school, perhaps? Even before the title page, a wordless frontmatter sequence begins the story. On the title page the dog's eyes clearly signal displeasure at having to come inside. "Squirrel," the hardest of the 10 words used, appears three times, providing practice while also making it clear that the squirrel is dog's chief antagonist. The repeated sentence structure helps build confidence and fosters reading fluency. Another successful addition to the I Like to Read series: "I see a winner!" (Early reader. 4-8)

COPYRIGHT(2017) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

January 1, 2018
A dog waits at home by looking outside at a series of animals through a sliding-glass door. Finally, the dog's boy arrives and the dog is free to chase the one animal he's repeatedly barked at: a squirrel. Each double-page spread contains at most one sentence, a boon to new readers. Expressive watercolor, acrylic, and pencil illustrations amusingly capture the dog's alternating boredom and excitement.

(Copyright 2018 by The Horn Book, Incorporated, Boston. All rights reserved.)